07-26-09
The ancillary events were held in the lawn of the WWI memorial in downtown KC. I was slated to help out at the Skill-shot challenge at noon so I got my round in and finished just in time to wander around and more or less schmooze for my allotted hour and helping out at least a little when needed.
I did well but not as well as last year. Greenwell seemed to have done substantially better than last year carding a strong 815 points and likely took the whole shebang.
In mini golf I shot a solid 58 in the big wind with 2 cut-throughs. Several of us were more than a little dismayed to find that most of the baskets were home made (or worse, the wham-o “toy” baskets) and weren’t stout enough to catch a golf mini. Climo had 4 bounce outs for deuce and one for ACE! (and he still beat me by two)
I have no idea why people adhere to the concept of “no-run-up” or “on-top-of-the-basket-is-good” in mini disc golf, but it persists.
After going to the Westin to check-in, I ran south to try to play the private course but it was blocked off with traffic cones so I couldn’t get it done. Maybe tomorrow.
OK…soap box time. And this is important if you EVER plan to design or build a course or run a tournament on one…
I want to say this NOW, before the very first competitive throw is made. Quite simply, the pin position selections for this year’s PDGAW do not “MOVE THE SCORE” effectively.
Don’t get me wrong…The courses are stunningly beautiful. Well manicured (especially Swope) great new signage (except Blue Valley) It’s obvious that the locals have done immense work to prepare their courses for the world stage…with one all important oversight.
The greater a person’s distance prowess, the greater their chances of scoring well. Finesse is all but completely forsaken. If a person cannot throw 400’, there will be precious few opportunities to gain a stroke on the field. I feel it is safe to say that these courses contain the highest percentage of par 4s of any previous PDGAW. An embarrassingly small percentage of these par 4s require an accurate placement shot off the tee.
I predict that what will follow is this:
There will be a congested pack in the upper middle of people who threw the courses well enough, but couldn’t quite reach their putting comfort zones; coming up just short on the birdie holes and hitting their solid 3’s or 4’s on the longer holes. Below them will be a ever-lengthening tail of people who didn’t throw well and lost strokes to the field.
Leading each division will be the people who CAN throw far and even though they may not have had a round filled with accurate shots, they had a few. By the virtue of their power, they will still gain strokes on the field with those shots that were accurate enough. And those will be enough to separate them from the bulging center of the pack.
I saw it in at the Melbourne Open. Something like 20 people within a couple of strokes after the first round, because the holes were too long to birdie and too short to be a par 4.
I just saw it again in Jax at WFDF’s first round. 16 of the 24 holes were between 340 and 440 and 12 of them were between 360 & 400. TWELVE! HALF of the hole lengths were within a 40 foot window!
The Worlds courses are stacking up to be along the same lines. EVERY course seems to be set up for GOLD level play, even if the GOLD level players don’t utilize the courses. How this could come to pass at a World Championship event is completely beyond me.
The power players won’t recognize this deficit in forethought because they WILL be reaching these pins where the rest of us are locked in a yawn-fest of par golf. I’m sad to report this, but watch the scores (especially in the non-open divisions) and pray that I’m wrong. I will.
The KC club has all the scores from the KC wide open, which should have given them all the information they needed about how to place holes that would spread out the scores.
I don’t believe that I was able to fully articulate my frustration with this ‘CRUSH OR BE CRUSHED’ course design ideology, but if you pay attention, I believe that you may see what many of us who depend upon our finesse games to out-smart or out-shoot our opponents are upset about.
Simply put…accuracy will be helpful, but power WILL win the KC PDGAW in 2009.
I need to point out that this is NOT just a KC thing. This is happening all over.
Granted, the Gold level players should be showcased. But what about the other 90% (or higher)?
Tomorrow: May rest, may not.
My picks for this year’s PDGAW.
Open: Avery if he keeps his head (backhand & sidearm). Climo if he can keep reeling in the 40 footers.
Masters: Schack should like his chances for a repeat. I do.
GM: “Baby-Grand” Jim Myers has the power and knows how to win.
Women’s Open: Val throws far and has a good putt
Advanced: Germ will clean up.
Juniors: Wiggins wings his way to a win.
The rest: Haven’t done my homework. sorry.